Supergirl vs Supergirl?! Part 2

Picking up right from where we left off with just a Crisis and a major status quo for the girl of steel happening since the last issue we covered, we now jump headfirst into the deep end of the Matrix Supergirl as she headlines her own title, but even by issue 2 of this mini series she’s not alone.

Supergirl (Vol. 3) #2 was part of a mini-series from 1994 that was released after the Death of Superman which made it cool and profitable to be a fan of the big S. Although the cover is full of Supergirl clones, the story barely features them. The story instead follows Supergirl as she visits Singapore and undergoes tests through the LexCorp facility stationed there. Here LexCorp, along with the reader, learns more about the upper limits of Supergirl’s powers especially in regards to her shapeshifting ability. While this is happening, Supergirl also meets Elizabeth Perske, a former wife of the first Lex Luthor, who tries to warn Supergirl about her new boyfriend Lex Luthor II. This drop of suspicion leads our hero to begin snooping in on various LexCorp employees where she learns they don’t think too fondly of her and view her merely as Luthor’s lapdog who will do whatever he says. The issue ends with Dr. Eller, who has been in charge of Supergirl’s testing, on the phone with Dr. Happersen, one of Lex Luthor’s main confidants. Happersen is shown in a room full of Supergirl Clones which he is calling “Operation: Protomatter” and urges Eller to keep Supergirl in Singapore, a task that Eller proclaims is just too easy when dealing with Lex’s Bimbo. Supergirl, in her snooping era, overhears Eller’s end of the conversation and the issue ends with Supergirl demanding to know everything Eller knows about “Operation: Protomatter”.

Moving forward again to Supergirl (Vol. 4) #30, from 1999, we are met with a rather menacing cover that features both Supergirl holding a skull, and also a shadowy Supergirl shaped figure sneaking up on her. When I was compiling this list I made a deliberate effort to not include Supergirl vs. Power Girl or Supergirl vs. Bizarro-Girl covers because those are also surprisingly frequent and as such fall into a different category than what I want to look at with these covers. With that being said, the backwards S on the shadowy Supergirl does have a bit of Bizarro in her look but she’s arguably more Supergirl than the protagonist. As I get into the story I’ll mostly gloss over the Cutter storyline since it doesn’t relate too much to the topic. Supergirl, returning to Leesburg from being out of town, is met with a city faced with a serial killer that has been dubbed the “Piranha”. Fred Danvers is caught in the clutches of this Piranha and finds out it’s none other than Matrix? Matrix is of course the protomatter Supergirl we mentioned in the last issue we discussed and the Supergirl that merged with Fred’s Daughter just 29 issues ago in this same title. So how are Matrix and Supergirl both walking around in Leesburg? The answer to this is of course because when Matrix merged with Linda not all of the protomatter was used and some got washed away into the sewers eventually reforming and growing sentience. After a brief tussle that involves a bit of introspection about which of them is the real Supergirl and if taking over Linda’s body was the morally right thing to do or a selfish conquest, Matrix seems to overtake Linda (Supergirl) Danvers. The issue is left on a cliff hanger where we see Matrix atop Fred Danvers’ car holding Supergirl’s costume in her hands as she screams “There’s just Matrix now! MAAAATRIIIIX!!!!”

Issue 73 of this same title, from a few years later in 2002, is quite similar to the last book discussed, issue 30. Here we are once again seeing our titular hero go against another possibly more true Supergirl, however the script has been flipped somewhat. Before we had Linda Danvers that had partially merged with the protomatter that was Supergirl, fighting the remainder of the protomatter. In this issue however Linda, now separated from the protomatter entirely, is facing against the Supergirl that is the earthborn angel. This is what she believes she is fighting at least. The story involves Linda, Buzz (the Demon), and Mary Marvel traveling to the point on earth where the Garden of Eden originally stood. Once they arrive a Supergirl with fiery wings attacks Linda and a battle ensues. It is however revealed that it is Bizarro Supergirl, with the help of the Demon Mother, controlling the earthborn angel. This does seem to go a bit against my rules of not including Bizarro Supergirl stories in this list but I think since there are 2 separate Supergirls shown in the story it should count on a technicality at the very least.

Another thing i tried to avoid doing while compiling this list was limiting storylines to a single issue to look at. In last week’s post we looked at issue 11 of The Daring New Adventures of Supergirl. That storyline also went into issue 12 of the title but I only included the first cover. So why is this different? Part of it is because of how far reaching this story, Many Happy Returns, is and part of it is because the difference in what’s happening in these 2 issues is such a major change, and part of it is because both of these are homage covers and I wanted to talk about that. Homage covers are going to become quite frequent in the remaining books as we close out this list and these 2 are homages to some of the most important moments in Kara Zor-El’s life; her arrival on earth, and her death. Supergirl (Vol. 4) #75 is an homage to Action Comics #252, the story of Supergirl first arriving on earth after being rocketed away from Argo. This issue tells a similar story, but instead of her rocket arriving on the pre-crisis earth as it should’ve, she instead lands on the post-crisis earth and meets a much different Supergirl. Their fight in this issue is quite brief and mostly boils down to a misunderstanding between the 2 gals of steel. Issue #79 is an homage to Crisis on Infinite Earths #7, part of the historic maxi-series and the issue where Supergirl meets her ultimate fate at the hands of the Anti-Monitor. The issue we’re discussing doesn’t actually feature any interaction between the 2 Supergirls and instead mostly showcases Linda’s life as she trades places and goes to where Kara should have gone. The story shows that Linda leads quite a full life on this earth that is sort of based on pre-crisis earth-1 but also has quite a few earth-2 characters. She becomes a hero to the world, has many adventures with Superman, eventually reveals to Superman she’s not who she says, and then marries him and has a daughter which then brings this issue up to 3 Supergirls. The issue ends with the Spectre telling Linda she has to go back to her own earth so that history can right itself with either Supergirl in their own universe fulfilling their own destinies.

Kara Zor-El returned to the main DC universe and got a new ongoing title in 2005 and very early on in issue 5 we get a new entry in the Supergirl vs Supergirl category. Supergirl (Vol. 5) #5 from 2006 has a cover with 2 Supergirls. One in the classic red and blue while the other has a predominantly black outfit. The issue shows a rather aggressive and brutal fight between the 2 Supergirls that takes up the majority of the issue. Through dialogue we get a better look at this Kara Zor-El’s origin that includes her father sending her to earth after Kal-El in order to kill him. Because this origin is told to us by the “evil” Supergirl its unclear whether or not what she said is true. The fight between them also briefly features a standoff with the Justice League before the duo of steel crash lands in Gotham Harbor. There is a brief bit of stalling from Batman before Superman and Wonder Woman enter the scene and the fight is finally decided after Wonder Woman lassos them both. After being compelled by the Lasso of Truth to reveal the true Kara Zor-El, the pair merges together. Kara explains that she doesn’t care what happened to her before she landed on earth, and what’s important is what she wants to do now and that is to be a hero.

Coming in just a year later we get a new Supergirl vs Supergirl story in issue #18 of the title. If this cover looks familiar, that’s because its a clear homage to the one we looked at before, issue #5. While the cover matches issue 5, the story also has some similarities to the Many Happy Returns storyline we discussed before that. In this issue Supergirl is having halucinations and struggling to fight the urges inside her to kill Superman. All while this is happening we’re introduced to a very happy-go-lucky Supergirl that once again seems to resemble the pre-crisis version. After a bit of fighting and the “perfect” Supergirl trying to convince Kara that she’s not the real Supergirl, our hero overcomes and it’s revealed that everything she’s been through has been the result of Dark Angel. Dark Angel had been sent by the Monitors to track down potential anomalies in the new post Infinite Crisis world and test them to see if they’re really supposed to be in this universe or not. Our hero does pass the test and a Monitor tells her that the information she’s come to know about her life on Krypton and what she knew of Zor-El was all fake and she wasn’t actually sent to earth to kill her cousin.

Supergirl (Vol. 6) #37 from 2015 is the next entry on our list and shows Supergirl fighting not one but three copies of herself in various familiar costumes. The story itself features very little Supergirl on Supergirl action and mostly explores the ongoing narrative of Kara in space school at Crucible. Crucible is a school for various young heroes from planets all over the galaxy to train and learn how to be better protectors of their home worlds. The issue follows Kara and her classmates – Maxima, Tsavo, and Comet – as they go through various lessons and tests in this space school. About halfway through the book we see the scene from the cover while Kara and Comet are doing an exercise somewhat like capture the flag. Supergirl seems to be easily overtaking Comet in the challenge when she’s suddenly swarmed by duplicates of herself. These duplicates are revealed to just be projections made by Comet to overpower Kara and allow him to win the challenge.

We now get to the last book in our list, Supergirl (Vol. 7) #28 from 2019. This issue opens with Supergirl, along with the Omega Men, fighting a horde of imperfect cones of herself. Seemingly overpowered, Supergirl asks Ryand’r, a Tamaranean, to give her a solar boost which allows her to preform a clap resulting in a stunning concussive blast. While only meaning to stun these monstrous clones, they instead perish due to the unstable nature of the cloning process done by Harry Hokum. After confronting Harry Hokum, Kara finds a new clue in her search for more clarification of the destruction of Krypton as Hokum points her towards The Circle before quickly teleporting away.

And with that we have completed looking at a bunch of comics that all feature Supergirl fighting herself in one way or another. As we left off last week we had 2 imposter stories, 1 alternate universe story, and 1 clone story. Surprisingly, we don’t have any more imposter stories to add to the list but we do have a new category in the form of split personalities which we saw in Supergirl (Vol. 4) issues 30 and 73 and Supergirl (Vol. 5) issue 5 giving us a total of 3 for that category. Vol. 4 issues 75 and 79 along with Vol. 5’s issue 18 gives us 3 more to add to the alternate universe category, since all 3 of those issues feature a pseudo pre-Crisis Supergirl which brings that total up to 4. and to close out our list we add Supergirl (Vol. 3) #2 and Supergirl (Vol. 7) #28 to the clone category leaving it with a total of 3. I’m unsure where exactly to categorize Supergirl (Vol. 6) #37 since it’s revealed to be just a projection but it seems most like the new split personality category so that can be bumped up to a total of 4.

Supergirl (vol. 8) #2 has come out now and it is unfortunately not Ellie Leeds in the role of the fake Supergirl, and is in fact Lesla-Lar. The direction of the story does seem very interesting and I’m excited to see how Sophie Campbell handles Lesla-Lar because she is one of my favorite Supergirl villains and she hasn’t seen much of the spotlight so far. As a whole I think the Supergirl vs Supergirl trope was a lot of fun to look at and explore and I think Supergirl is a great character to look at fighting herself. Supergirl has had a lot of identity issues trying to adjust to life as a human when she spent so much time on Krypton or the Matrix having trouble viewing herself as more than just a science experiment. So these broader ideas really help open the character up to fighting a physical manifestation of herself while also allowing introspection about who the real Supergirl is.

I hope you enjoyed reading this extensive look at Supergirl vs Supergirl and I hope you stick around for many more posts about the girl of steel. If you have and thought or suggestions feel free to email me at blogofsupergirl@gmail.com.